Christopher Cashell (topher) wrote,
Christopher Cashell

Debian vs. Red Hat, for package management.

In one of his entries today, revjim expressed some frustration with Red Hat's package system (RPM) and at the end of his entry, asked how Debian's compares. As a very happy Debian user, I responded. After seeing what I'd written, I figure I'll post it here, too. I'll also flesh it out with more information after I get home tonight. ;-)

To put it simply, Debian's packaging system in comparison with Red Hat's is like comparing the Empire State Building with a crumbling shack in a downtown slum. ;-)

One of the primary reasons, is that Debian packages all[*] come from Debian. Red Hat packages are created by third parties as often, if not more so, than by Red Hat. This means that there is a much lower level of quality control among Red Hat packages, and a much greater variation in quality.

Secondly, there is a difference in how dependancies work. In Red Hat, packages are dependant on specific files. In Debian, packages are only dependant on other packages. This makes them, in my experience, more reliable. They won't break because a single file may have been moved.

Also, Debian has a reputation, and actively works to maintian it, for stability and reliability. It may not always be cutting edge (Assuming that you are using 'stable'. If you use 'unstable', which is still as stable as most other distro's stable in my opinion, you may occasionally run into problems) but it will be rock solid.

My first distribution was Red Hat, and I tried out a number of others early on, but ever since I installed Debian, I've never felt like I was missing anything. Once you try apt, you'll never want to give it up. ;-)

I'll take some time when I get home tonight to talk more about Debian, and prolly put it in a journal entry. Or, feel free to talk to me online, and I can tell you 'bout it, or answer any questions. An intersting thing to note, though, is that among the SorceryNet 'staff' people who run Linux, more of them run Debian than anything else. ;-)

[*] Debian has an open policy that allows just about anyone to become a package maintainer. When this happens, they get some training, mentoring, practice, and become a Debian developer. This ensures higher quality packages, better testing, and allows you to get all packages from a single source.

  • Google Buzz.

    This is a (probably temporary) post to attempt to integrate my LiveJournal into Google Buzz.

  • The BEST player in College Football in 2009: Ndamukong Suh

    A lot of people have trouble understanding how good Ndamukong Suh, the Defensive Tackle for the Nebraska Cornhuskers really is. There aren't many…

  • Customer Service done wrong.

    So, after having finally purchased a house, I went to get cable and Internet setup. Like most of the country, I live in an unfortunate area where…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded